Skip to content
citysupplyfayetteville
New + Notable
See what's new!
Halloween Collection
NEW! Broken Bow
Razorbacks
Hunting Season
Fishing Season
Shop the Trend: Howdy Drop
Butter Lovers
Arkansas Makers
Shop the Trend: Striped and Scalloped
Coffee Tea and Pink House Alchemy
The Pet Shop
Fayetteville Collection
Shop all products
Shop By Brand
Allegiance Flag Supply
Amigo Provisions
Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
Aunt Susie's Granola
Bittermilk
Bloody Darn Good
Broken Bow
Burlebo
City Supply Exclusives
Duncan + Stone
Fatworks
Frankie's Fine Brine
Guenther Apiary
Hammond's Candies
Haute Diggity Dog
House of Webster
Jack Rudy
Junk Brands
Lodge
Lost & Found Collective
Mollyjogger
Nebo
Old School Mill
The Old Try
Onyx Coffee Lab
Oxford Pennant
Pappy & Co
Pickwick & Co
Pink House Alchemy
The Real Dill
Sip Hip Hooray
Slightly Stationary
Spiceology
Stanley
Well Told
War Eagle Mill
Wright's Barbecue
Nostalgia + Novelty
Stickers + Small Souvenirs
Old-School Toys + Games
Funny Gifts + Knickknacks
City Supply Exclusives + Collaborations
Fayetteville Favorites
Arkansas Makers
Arkansas Makers
SALE
Subscriptions
Shop By Collection
Back to School
Dog Days of Summer
Coffee and Tea collection
The Tailgate Collection
Halloween
Arkansas Razorbacks
Fayetteville Farmer's Market
The Masters
Baseball Season
Camping
Hunting Season
Fishing Season
Fayetteville Arkansas
Nostalgic and humorous
Arkansas Makers
Middle Earth
Children's Safety Center
The Button Bar
Strawberry Collection
Striped and Scalloped
Out On The Water
0
citysupplyfayetteville
0
New + Notable
See what's new!
Halloween Collection
NEW! Broken Bow
Razorbacks
Hunting Season
Fishing Season
Shop the Trend: Howdy Drop
Butter Lovers
Arkansas Makers
Shop the Trend: Striped and Scalloped
Coffee Tea and Pink House Alchemy
The Pet Shop
Fayetteville Collection
Shop all products
Shop By Brand
Allegiance Flag Supply
Amigo Provisions
Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
Aunt Susie's Granola
Bittermilk
Bloody Darn Good
Broken Bow
Burlebo
City Supply Exclusives
Duncan + Stone
Fatworks
Frankie's Fine Brine
Guenther Apiary
Hammond's Candies
Haute Diggity Dog
House of Webster
Jack Rudy
Junk Brands
Lodge
Lost & Found Collective
Mollyjogger
Nebo
Old School Mill
The Old Try
Onyx Coffee Lab
Oxford Pennant
Pappy & Co
Pickwick & Co
Pink House Alchemy
The Real Dill
Sip Hip Hooray
Slightly Stationary
Spiceology
Stanley
Well Told
War Eagle Mill
Wright's Barbecue
Nostalgia + Novelty
Stickers + Small Souvenirs
Old-School Toys + Games
Funny Gifts + Knickknacks
City Supply Exclusives + Collaborations
Fayetteville Favorites
Arkansas Makers
Arkansas Makers
SALE
Subscriptions
Shop By Collection
Back to School
Dog Days of Summer
Coffee and Tea collection
The Tailgate Collection
Halloween
Arkansas Razorbacks
Fayetteville Farmer's Market
The Masters
Baseball Season
Camping
Hunting Season
Fishing Season
Fayetteville Arkansas
Nostalgic and humorous
Arkansas Makers
Middle Earth
Children's Safety Center
The Button Bar
Strawberry Collection
Striped and Scalloped
Out On The Water
New + Notable
New + Notable
See what's new!
Halloween Collection
NEW! Broken Bow
Razorbacks
Hunting Season
Fishing Season
Shop the Trend: Howdy Drop
Butter Lovers
Arkansas Makers
Shop the Trend: Striped and Scalloped
Coffee Tea and Pink House Alchemy
The Pet Shop
Fayetteville Collection
Shop all products
Shop By Brand
Shop By Brand
Allegiance Flag Supply
Amigo Provisions
Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
Aunt Susie's Granola
Bittermilk
Bloody Darn Good
Broken Bow
Burlebo
City Supply Exclusives
Duncan + Stone
Fatworks
Frankie's Fine Brine
Guenther Apiary
Hammond's Candies
Haute Diggity Dog
House of Webster
Jack Rudy
Junk Brands
Lodge
Lost & Found Collective
Mollyjogger
Nebo
Old School Mill
The Old Try
Onyx Coffee Lab
Oxford Pennant
Pappy & Co
Pickwick & Co
Pink House Alchemy
The Real Dill
Sip Hip Hooray
Slightly Stationary
Spiceology
Stanley
Well Told
War Eagle Mill
Wright's Barbecue
Nostalgia + Novelty
Nostalgia + Novelty
Stickers + Small Souvenirs
Old-School Toys + Games
Funny Gifts + Knickknacks
City Supply Exclusives + Collaborations
Fayetteville Favorites
Arkansas Makers
Arkansas Makers
SALE
Subscriptions
Shop By Collection
Shop By Collection
Back to School
Dog Days of Summer
Coffee and Tea collection
The Tailgate Collection
Halloween
Arkansas Razorbacks
Fayetteville Farmer's Market
The Masters
Baseball Season
Camping
Hunting Season
Fishing Season
Fayetteville Arkansas
Nostalgic and humorous
Arkansas Makers
Middle Earth
Children's Safety Center
The Button Bar
Strawberry Collection
Striped and Scalloped
Out On The Water
Register / Login
Clear
Popular collections
Bestsellers
Arkansas Makers
In-Store Sweets & Treats
Frozen or refrigerated items are only available for purchase in the shop!
7 Results
Sort: Alphabetically, A-Z
Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Clear filters
Sort
Quick View
Astronaut Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwich
$7.99
Unit price
/
per
Quick View
Chocolate Mini Moonpie
$1.99
Unit price
/
per
Quick View
Chocolate Moonpie
$2.99
Unit price
/
per
Quick View
Jelly Belly: Buttered Popcorn
$3.99
Unit price
/
per
Sold out
Quick View
Maple Bacon Pop
$5.99
Unit price
/
per
Quick View
Old School Brand™ - Peppermint Puffs
$9.99
Unit price
/
per
Quick View
Vanilla Mini Moonpie
$1.99
Unit price
/
per
You’re viewing 1-7 of 7 products
Sort
Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
SHOP MORE COLLECTIONS
OUR MOST POPULAR
Arkansas Makers
City Supply Exclusives + Collaborations
Bestsellers
Razorbacks
Pantry + Barware
Books
Outdoors
Availability
