Skip to content
  • New Arrivals
  • Gifts
    • Gift Card
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • Gifts Above $100
    • Gifts Under $30
    • Gifts for Him
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Baby
    • Teacher Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Housewarming
    • Wedding
  • Collections
    • Easter
    • Baseball
    • Coffee + Honey
    • City Supply Exclusives
    • Arkansas Maker
    • Fayetteville, Arkansas
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • National Parks
    • Tequila + Tex Mex
    • Tailgate Season
    • Arkansas Razorbacks
    • Sustainable Living
  • Shop by Brand
    • Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
    • Bella Cucina
    • Bittermilk
    • Callie's Charleston Biscuits
    • Guenther Apiary
    • Haute Diggity Dog
    • House of Webster
    • Jack Rudy
    • Lovestruck Co
    • Lucy & Co
    • Mollyjogger
    • The Old Try
    • Onyx Coffee Lab
    • Oxford Pennant
    • Pappy & Co
    • Petersen Family Farms
    • Pickwick & Co
    • Pink House Alchemy
    • The Real Dill
    • Spiceology
    • Signet Sealed Illustration
    • Stanley
    • Sugarboo & Co
    • Tennessee Peanut Co
    • True South Puzzle
    • Walker's Feed Co
    • Well Told
    • War Eagle Mill
    • WithCo Cocktails
    • Wright's Barbecue
  • Pantry + Barware
    • All Pantry + Barware
    • Breakfast
      • All Breakfast
      • Jams + Jellies
    • Supper
    • Snacks
    • Sweets
    • Coffee
    • Syrups
    • Cocktails
    • Spice Blends
    • Honey
  • Home
    • Kitchenware
      • All Kitchenware
      • Kitchen Linens
      • Mugs
      • Drinkware
      • Serveware
    • Decor
      • All Decor
      • Prints
      • Pillows + Throws
      • Pennants + Camp Flags
      • Doormats
    • Books
      • All Books
      • Cookbooks
      • Children's Books
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Paper Goods
      • All Paper Goods
      • Cards
      • Stickers
      • Magnets
      • Notebooks
      • Notepads
      • Planners + Calendars
    • Candles
    • Soaps + Cleaning
    • Puzzles + Games
  • Personal + Family
    • Apparel
      • Tee Shirts
      • Kids tees + Baby onesies
    • Accessories
    • Kids + Baby
      • Kids Tees + Baby Onesies
      • Childhood Toys
      • Children's Books
    • Pets
      • All Pets
      • Dog Toys
      • Pet Accessories
    • Grooming
    • Travel
  • Outdoors + Grilling
    • Camping
    • Grilling
    • Spice Blends
    • Backyard
    • Garden
  • SALE
  • Log in
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Cart
Search
citysupplyfayetteville citysupplyfayetteville
Log in Search Cart
  • New Arrivals
  • Gifts
    • Gift Card
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • Gifts Above $100
    • Gifts Under $30
    • Gifts for Him
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Baby
    • Teacher Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Housewarming
    • Wedding
  • Collections
    • Easter
    • Baseball
    • Coffee + Honey
    • City Supply Exclusives
    • Arkansas Maker
    • Fayetteville, Arkansas
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • National Parks
    • Tequila + Tex Mex
    • Tailgate Season
    • Arkansas Razorbacks
    • Sustainable Living
  • Shop by Brand
    • Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
    • Bella Cucina
    • Bittermilk
    • Callie's Charleston Biscuits
    • Guenther Apiary
    • Haute Diggity Dog
    • House of Webster
    • Jack Rudy
    • Lovestruck Co
    • Lucy & Co
    • Mollyjogger
    • The Old Try
    • Onyx Coffee Lab
    • Oxford Pennant
    • Pappy & Co
    • Petersen Family Farms
    • Pickwick & Co
    • Pink House Alchemy
    • The Real Dill
    • Spiceology
    • Signet Sealed Illustration
    • Stanley
    • Sugarboo & Co
    • Tennessee Peanut Co
    • True South Puzzle
    • Walker's Feed Co
    • Well Told
    • War Eagle Mill
    • WithCo Cocktails
    • Wright's Barbecue
  • Pantry + Barware
    • All Pantry + Barware
    • Breakfast
      • All Breakfast
      • Jams + Jellies
    • Supper
    • Snacks
    • Sweets
    • Coffee
    • Syrups
    • Cocktails
    • Spice Blends
    • Honey
  • Home
    • Kitchenware
      • All Kitchenware
      • Kitchen Linens
      • Mugs
      • Drinkware
      • Serveware
    • Decor
      • All Decor
      • Prints
      • Pillows + Throws
      • Pennants + Camp Flags
      • Doormats
    • Books
      • All Books
      • Cookbooks
      • Children's Books
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Paper Goods
      • All Paper Goods
      • Cards
      • Stickers
      • Magnets
      • Notebooks
      • Notepads
      • Planners + Calendars
    • Candles
    • Soaps + Cleaning
    • Puzzles + Games
  • Personal + Family
    • Apparel
      • Tee Shirts
      • Kids tees + Baby onesies
    • Accessories
    • Kids + Baby
      • Kids Tees + Baby Onesies
      • Childhood Toys
      • Children's Books
    • Pets
      • All Pets
      • Dog Toys
      • Pet Accessories
    • Grooming
    • Travel
  • Outdoors + Grilling
    • Camping
    • Grilling
    • Spice Blends
    • Backyard
    • Garden
  • SALE

Halloween

Sold Out
Goo Goo Cluster: Individual Original
$2.00
Sold Out
Goo Goo Cluster: Original 3 Count Box
$6.00
Quick view
Goo Goo Cluster: Collector’s Tin
$22.00
Sold Out
True South Puzzle: Classic Horror Movies
$26.95
Quick view
Crow Canyon Home: Black Enamel Mug
$10.00
Save $2.99
Quick view
Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags
Regular price $10.99 Sale price $8.00
Save $8.00
Quick view
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Regular price $20.00 Sale price $12.00
Save $7.00
Quick view
Trickster Box of Pranks
Regular price $14.00 Sale price $7.00
Save $7.00
Quick view
Prankster Box of Tricks
Regular price $14.00 Sale price $7.00
Quick view
WithCo: Sweater Weather
$20.00
Goo Goo Cluster: Collector’s Tin
Goo Goo Cluster: Collector’s Tin
Goo Goo Cluster: Collector’s Tin
Goo Goo Cluster: Collector’s Tin

Goo Goo Cluster: Collector’s Tin

Regular price $22.00
Sweet memories are wrapped up in our collector’s tin: eight (8) individually wrapped goo goos and a visual history lesson on america's first combination candy bar. Contains four (4) original, two (2) pecan, and two (2) peanut butter goo goo clusters.
Crow Canyon Home: Black Enamel Mug
Crow Canyon Home: Black Enamel Mug

Crow Canyon Home: Black Enamel Mug

Regular price $10.00

Serve your favorite beverages in our 16oz enamelware mug.

5" x 4" x 3.5".

Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags
Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags
Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags
Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags
Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags
Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags

Piper & Leaf Artisan Tea Co: Pumpkin Moonshine - 9 Tea Bags

Regular price $10.99 Sale price $8.00

Sachet muslin bags of our Pumpkin Moonshine black tea blend - a Fall seasonal. Each bag contains 9 single-serving, silky sachets in a hand-printed muslin bag! Sweet Roaster Pumpkins add a special malty oomph to the friendly warmth of the ginger and cinnamon, brought home by sweet anise notes.

Ingredients: Ceylon Black Tea, Pumpkin, Ginger, Clove, Star Anise, Cinnamon, Orange Rind, Organic Natural Flavor, Calendula, Black Pepper

Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug
Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug

Cami Monet - You Had Me at Pumpkin Spice Mug

Regular price $20.00 Sale price $12.00
If you can't wait for cozy sweaters, autumn bonfires and of course, the cinnamon-pumpkin goodness of a hot pumpkin spice latte, this mug is perfect for you! Share your love of all things pumpkin spice with your new favorite coffee mug that features a watercolor PSL one side and watercolor brush lettering that says "you had me at pumpkin spice" on the other side. Mugs are 11 oz. 3.7"H x 3.2".
Trickster Box of Pranks
Trickster Box of Pranks

Trickster Box of Pranks

Regular price $14.00 Sale price $7.00

Includes: Nail with bandage, mini whoopee cushion, gum with roach, scary spider, and fake poop

Ages 8 and up

Prankster Box of Tricks
Prankster Box of Tricks

Prankster Box of Tricks

Regular price $14.00 Sale price $7.00

Includes: Throw-up, chocolate with spider, trick teeth, thumb trick, fake poop, and a roach.

Ages 8 and up

WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather
WithCo: Sweater Weather

WithCo: Sweater Weather

Regular price $20.00

Turning leaves, fireside chats, and #sweaterweather go hand in hand. Our apple cider-esque cocktail boasts our longest list of fresh, hand sourced ingredients, to make hosting and gathering a breeze. It’s comforting aroma and subtle spices will make this a family tradition worth keeping.

 

Each 16 oz bottle makes 10 cocktails. 

*Can be served warm in a crock-pot or sauce pan

INGREDIENTS
Apple, Raw Honey, Lemon, Cinnamon, Cloves, Cardamon, Rosemary, Bay Leaf, All spice, Orange, Cayenne

TASTE
Balanced, Comforting, Aromatic 

PAIR
Bourbon, Whiskey, Scotch

NUTRITION
Serving Size / 1.5 oz
Servings Per Container / 10
Calories / 30
Calories from Fat / 0
Total Fat / 0 / Daily Value / 0%
Saturated Fat / 0 / Daily Value 0%
Sodium / 0 mg / Daily Value 0%
Carbohydrates / 7 g / Daily Value 2%
Sugars / 6 g
Protein / 0 g

Footer menu

  • Return Policy and Return Portal
  • Online and In-store Support and FAQ
  • Search
  • PRIVACY POLICY

Sign up and save

Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.

Our shop is dog friendly. Please come stop in and say hi and/or buy stuff.

Looking for us?  Something else nagging you? Give us a shout.

Phone No. 479-304-8459

For General inquiries and order questions, hit up citysupplyfayetteville@gmail.com.

COME VISIT!

15 S. BLOCK AVENUE SUITE 101

FAYETTEVILLE, AR 72701

(ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE SQUARE)

  • amazon payments
  • american express
  • apple pay
  • discover
  • google pay
  • master
  • visa