Nostalgic Christmas

Bring back the magic of Christmases past with our Nostalgic Christmas collection — a cheerful mix of classic movie moments, retro toys, and timeless treasures that spark pure holiday joy. From playful stocking stuffers to keepsakes that feel straight out of your childhood, every piece celebrates the simple, heartwarming traditions we never outgrow. It’s cozy, colorful, and just the right amount of kitschy — the kind of Christmas that makes you smile before you even plug in the lights.

36 Results

Clear filters
City Supply Vanilla Marshmallows
ARKANSAS MAKER

City Supply Vanilla Marshmallows

$14.99

Key Chain Tape Measure

Key Chain Tape Measure

$4.99

City Supply Bourbon Marshmallows
ARKANSAS MAKER

City Supply Bourbon Marshmallows

$14.99

City Supply Classic Hot Cocoa - 12oz
Sold out

City Supply Classic Hot Cocoa - 12oz

$19.99

City Supply Peppermint Marshmallows
ARKANSAS MAKER

City Supply Peppermint Marshmallows

$14.99

City Supply Peppermint Hot Cocoa - 12oz
ARKANSAS MAKER

City Supply Peppermint Hot Cocoa - 12oz

$19.99

Original Silly Putty

Original Silly Putty

$3.99

Whoopee Cushion

Whoopee Cushion

$3.99

Kid's Duck Call

Kid's Duck Call

$9.99

Metal Harmonica

Metal Harmonica

$8.99

Metal Kazoo

Metal Kazoo

$3.99

Smiley Bendy Man 5"

Smiley Bendy Man 5"

$3.99

The Night Before Christmas- Children's Vintage Book

The Night Before Christmas- Children's Vintage Book

$19.99

Beetle & Bee Bird Call

Beetle & Bee Bird Call

$8.99

Hand Buzzer

Hand Buzzer

$5.99

Neato! Wood Yo-Yo

Neato! Wood Yo-Yo

$5.99

Christmas in the Movies: 30 Classics to Celebrate the Season

Christmas in the Movies: 30 Classics to Celebrate the Season

$24.99

Bird Whistle Toy

Bird Whistle Toy

$3.99

Holiday Conversation Cards

Holiday Conversation Cards

$20.99

The Night Before Christmas Oversized Padded Board Book
Sold out

The Night Before Christmas Oversized Padded Board Book

$13.99

Night Before Christmas by Clement C. Moore- Blue

Night Before Christmas by Clement C. Moore- Blue

$17.99

Santa & One Reindeer - Christmas Card
Sold out

Santa & One Reindeer - Christmas Card

$6.99

Duncan & Stone - Holiday Memory Book & Family Keepsake | Emerald
ARKANSAS MAKER

Duncan & Stone - Holiday Memory Book & Family Keepsake | Emerald

$22.99

Very Vintage Christmas

Very Vintage Christmas

$24.99

Christmas Snow Globe

Christmas Snow Globe

$29.99

Santa Jack in the Box
Sold out

Santa Jack in the Box

$40.99

Fly eye scope

Fly eye scope

$5.99

Christmas Dinner - Christmas Card
Sold out

Christmas Dinner - Christmas Card

$6.99

Santa Taking Off - Christmas Card

Santa Taking Off - Christmas Card

$6.99

Maple Candle in Can Crackling Wood Wick

Maple Candle in Can Crackling Wood Wick

$29.99

A Vintage Christmas: A Collection of Classic Stories & Poem

A Vintage Christmas: A Collection of Classic Stories & Poem

$16.99

Treats for Santa - Christmas Greeting Card

Treats for Santa - Christmas Greeting Card

$6.99

SHOP MORE COLLECTIONS

OUR MOST POPULAR
Arkansas Makers

Arkansas Makers

City Supply Exclusives

City Supply Exclusives

Bestsellers

Razorbacks

Razorbacks

Pantry + Barware

Pantry + Barware

Books

Books

Outdoors

Outdoors