Skip to content

citysupplyfayetteville

Arkansas Tailgate Collection
Corporate Gifting
Subscriptions
SALE

citysupplyfayetteville

Arkansas Tailgate Collection
New + Notable
Corporate Gifting
Shop By Category
Shop By Brand
Shop By Collection
Subscriptions
SALE

Register / Login

Popular collections

Arkansas Makers

Sweets

38 Results

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

0 selected

In stock (37)
Out of stock (1)

The highest price is $80.99

$ From

–

$ To

Aunt Susie's Granola- Coffee Cake

ARKANSAS MAKER

Aunt Susie's Granola- Coffee Cake

$12.99

Unit price: per

Aunt Susie's Granola- Chocolate Chip Cookie

ARKANSAS MAKER

Aunt Susie's Granola- Chocolate Chip Cookie

$12.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand- Caramel Popcorn

$9.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand - Cinnabutter Puffs

$7.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand - Buttermint Puffs

$7.99

Unit price: per

Goo Goo Cluster - Peanut Butter

Goo Goo Cluster - Peanut Butter

$2.99

Unit price: per

Vintage Reproduction Batter Bowl

Vintage Reproduction Batter Bowl

$80.99

Unit price: per

Ozark Nut Roasters - Dark Chocolate Espresso Beans

ARKANSAS MAKER

Ozark Nut Roasters - Dark Chocolate Espresso Beans

$11.99

Unit price: per

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Cashews - 4oz

ARKANSAS MAKER

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Cashews - 4oz

$6.99

Unit price: per

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Sunflower Seeds

ARKANSAS MAKER

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Sunflower Seeds

$6.99

Unit price: per

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Rocks - 4oz

ARKANSAS MAKER

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Rocks - 4oz

$6.99

Unit price: per

Ozark Nut Roasters- Chocolate Almonds- 4oz

ARKANSAS MAKER

Ozark Nut Roasters- Chocolate Almonds- 4oz

$6.99

Unit price: per

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Rocks - 8oz

ARKANSAS MAKER

Ozark Nut Roasters - Chocolate Rocks - 8oz

$11.99

Unit price: per

The Perfect Man Milk Chocolate

The Perfect Man Milk Chocolate

$3.99

Unit price: per

Hill City Popcorn X City Supply- The Tallulah

Hill City Popcorn X City Supply- The Tallulah

$10.99

Unit price: per

Cookie Dough Scoop

Cookie Dough Scoop

$11.99

Unit price: per

Just A Pinch Measuring Spoons

Just A Pinch Measuring Spoons

$6.99

Unit price: per

The Cookie That Changed My Life Cookbook

The Cookie That Changed My Life Cookbook

$40.99

Unit price: per

The Perfect Man - Chocolate bite size

The Perfect Man - Chocolate bite size

$2.99

Unit price: per

Chocolate Red Foiled Rose

Chocolate Red Foiled Rose

$3.99

Unit price: per

City Supply Ice Cream Pint Sleeve

City Supply Ice Cream Pint Sleeve

$4.99

Unit price: per

Jeni's: Desserts Cookbook

Jeni's: Desserts Cookbook

$24.99

Unit price: per

Ring and Funnel

Ring and Funnel

$21.99

Unit price: per

Rainbow Blast Lollipop

Rainbow Blast Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price: per

MoonPie Party In A Box

MoonPie Party In A Box

$29.99

Unit price: per

Red Wax Lips

Sold out

Red Wax Lips

$4.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand: Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix

$8.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand™ - Premium Peanut Brittle

$15.99

Unit price: per

Cinnamon Grab-n-Go Drops

Cinnamon Grab-n-Go Drops

$3.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand: Red Velvet Cake Mix

$8.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand: Pound Cake Mix

$8.99

Unit price: per

Old School Brand: Cobbler Mix

$8.99

Unit price: per

1
2

You’re viewing 1-32 of 38 products

Filter

In stock (37)
Out of stock (1)

$ From

–

$ To

The highest price is $80.99

38 Results

Sort

Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

SHOP MORE COLLECTIONS

OUR MOST POPULAR

Arkansas Makers

Arkansas Makers

City Supply Exclusives

City Supply Exclusives

Bestsellers

Razorbacks

Razorbacks

Pantry + Barware

Pantry + Barware

Books

Books

Outdoors

Outdoors

Our shop is dog friendly. Please come stop in and say hi and/or buy stuff.

Looking for us? Something else nagging you? Give us a shout.

Phone No. 479-304-8459

For General inquiries and order questions, hit up citysupplyfayetteville@gmail.com.

INFORMATION + LINKS

Texting Is Easier! Join now.
Holler at us.
About Us: City Supply + The Mormans
Customer Service
Shipping
Collabs + Affiliates
In-Store Sweets + Treats
Corporate + Bulk Gifting
Return Policy + Returns
Donation Requests
Frequently Asked Questions
Privacy Policy

STORE HOURS

monday-saturday 10am-6pm

sunday NOON-5PM

15 S. BLOCK AVENUE

FAYETTEVILLE AR, 72701

Newsletter

Your email

Copyright © 2025, citysupplyfayetteville. All rights reserved. See our terms of use and privacy notice.

Powered by Shopify

Availability