Your cart

Your cart is empty

Have you shopped our all-time bestsellers?

Sweets

66 Results

Easter Bon Bons - 15-pack

Easter Bon Bons - 15-pack

$49.99

Unit price
per 

Easter Bon Bons - 5-pack

Easter Bon Bons - 5-pack

$18.99

Unit price
per 

What's For Dessert

What's For Dessert

$35.99

Unit price
per 

The Good Book Of Southern Baking

The Good Book Of Southern Baking

$35.99

Unit price
per 

Very Berry Lollipop

Very Berry Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Birthday Cake Lollipop

Birthday Cake Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Cotton Candy Egg Lollipop

Cotton Candy Egg Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Grape Egg Lollipop

Grape Egg Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Cacao Nib Caramels

Pappy & Co: Cacao Nib Caramels

$28.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Ghost Pepper Caramels

Pappy & Co: Ghost Pepper Caramels

$28.99

Unit price
per 

Sunny Seeds Carrot

Sunny Seeds Carrot

$4.99

Unit price
per 

Pastel Sunny Seeds

Pastel Sunny Seeds

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Chocolate Colorful Candy River Rocks

Chocolate Colorful Candy River Rocks

$4.99

Unit price
per 

Vanilla Mini Moonpies - Box of 12

Vanilla Mini Moonpies - Box of 12

$19.99

Unit price
per 

Chocolate Mini Moonpies - Box of 12

Chocolate Mini Moonpies - Box of 12

$19.99

Unit price
per 

Chocolate Moonpies - Box of 12

Chocolate Moonpies - Box of 12

$22.99

Unit price
per 

Vanilla Moonpies - Box of 12

Vanilla Moonpies - Box of 12

$22.99

Unit price
per 

Organic Cherry Lollipop

Organic Cherry Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Rainbow Blast Spiral Lollipop Bundles

Rainbow Blast Spiral Lollipop Bundles

$4.99

Unit price
per 

Rainbow Blast Lollipop

Rainbow Blast Lollipop

$3.99

Unit price
per 

Solid Cookies & Cream Bunny - PICK UP ONLY
MoonPie Party In A Box

MoonPie Party In A Box

$29.99

Unit price
per 

Markham + Fitz: Chocolate Truffle Assortment - 15pc
ARKANSAS MAKER
Markham + Fitz: Sea Salt Caramels - 5pc
ARKANSAS MAKER

Markham + Fitz: Sea Salt Caramels - 5pc

$13.99

Unit price
per 

Claey’s Licorice Sanded Hard Candy

Claey’s Licorice Sanded Hard Candy

$4.99

Unit price
per 

Claey’s Cinnamon Sanded Hard Candy

Claey’s Cinnamon Sanded Hard Candy

$4.99

Unit price
per 

Claey’s Sassafras Sanded Hard Candy

Claey’s Sassafras Sanded Hard Candy

$4.99

Unit price
per 

Hammond's Candies: Cinnamon Drops Tin

Hammond's Candies: Cinnamon Drops Tin

$12.99

Unit price
per 

Bourbon Smoked Sugar

Bourbon Smoked Sugar

$15.00

Unit price
per 

Old School Mill: Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
Sold out
Stone Hollow Farmstead: Brandied Plum + Pecan Compote
Stone Hollow Farmstead: Dulce De Leche
Sold out

Stone Hollow Farmstead: Dulce De Leche

$16.00

Unit price
per