Skip to content
  • New Arrivals
  • Gifts
    • Gift Card
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • Gifts Above $100
    • Gifts Under $30
    • Gifts for Him
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Baby
    • Teacher Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Housewarming
    • Wedding
  • Collections
    • Easter
    • Baseball
    • Coffee + Honey
    • City Supply Exclusives
    • Arkansas Maker
    • Fayetteville, Arkansas
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • National Parks
    • Tequila + Tex Mex
    • Tailgate Season
    • Arkansas Razorbacks
    • Sustainable Living
  • Shop by Brand
    • Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
    • Bella Cucina
    • Bittermilk
    • Callie's Charleston Biscuits
    • Guenther Apiary
    • Haute Diggity Dog
    • House of Webster
    • Jack Rudy
    • Lovestruck Co
    • Lucy & Co
    • Mollyjogger
    • The Old Try
    • Onyx Coffee Lab
    • Oxford Pennant
    • Pappy & Co
    • Petersen Family Farms
    • Pickwick & Co
    • Pink House Alchemy
    • Spiceology
    • Signet Sealed Illustration
    • Stanley
    • Sugarboo & Co
    • Tennessee Peanut Co
    • True South Puzzle
    • Walker's Feed Co
    • Well Told
    • War Eagle Mill
    • WithCo Cocktails
    • Wright's Barbecue
  • Pantry + Barware
    • All Pantry + Barware
    • Breakfast
      • All Breakfast
      • Jams + Jellies
    • Supper
    • Snacks
    • Sweets
    • Coffee
    • Syrups
    • Cocktails
    • Spice Blends
    • Honey
  • Home
    • Kitchenware
      • All Kitchenware
      • Kitchen Linens
      • Mugs
      • Drinkware
      • Serveware
    • Decor
      • All Decor
      • Prints
      • Pillows + Throws
      • Pennants + Camp Flags
      • Doormats
    • Books
      • All Books
      • Cookbooks
      • Children's Books
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Paper Goods
      • All Paper Goods
      • Cards
      • Stickers
      • Magnets
      • Notebooks
      • Notepads
      • Planners + Calendars
    • Candles
    • Soaps + Cleaning
    • Puzzles + Games
  • Personal + Family
    • Apparel
      • Tee Shirts
      • Kids tees + Baby onesies
    • Accessories
    • Kids + Baby
      • Kids Tees + Baby Onesies
      • Childhood Toys
      • Children's Books
    • Pets
      • All Pets
      • Dog Toys
      • Pet Accessories
    • Grooming
    • Travel
  • Outdoors + Grilling
    • Camping
    • Grilling
    • Spice Blends
    • Backyard
    • Garden
  • SALE
  • Log in
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Cart
Search
citysupplyfayetteville citysupplyfayetteville
Log in Search Cart
  • New Arrivals
  • Gifts
    • Gift Card
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • Gifts Above $100
    • Gifts Under $30
    • Gifts for Him
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Baby
    • Teacher Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Housewarming
    • Wedding
  • Collections
    • Easter
    • Baseball
    • Coffee + Honey
    • City Supply Exclusives
    • Arkansas Maker
    • Fayetteville, Arkansas
    • Curated Gift Sets
    • National Parks
    • Tequila + Tex Mex
    • Tailgate Season
    • Arkansas Razorbacks
    • Sustainable Living
  • Shop by Brand
    • Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
    • Bella Cucina
    • Bittermilk
    • Callie's Charleston Biscuits
    • Guenther Apiary
    • Haute Diggity Dog
    • House of Webster
    • Jack Rudy
    • Lovestruck Co
    • Lucy & Co
    • Mollyjogger
    • The Old Try
    • Onyx Coffee Lab
    • Oxford Pennant
    • Pappy & Co
    • Petersen Family Farms
    • Pickwick & Co
    • Pink House Alchemy
    • Spiceology
    • Signet Sealed Illustration
    • Stanley
    • Sugarboo & Co
    • Tennessee Peanut Co
    • True South Puzzle
    • Walker's Feed Co
    • Well Told
    • War Eagle Mill
    • WithCo Cocktails
    • Wright's Barbecue
  • Pantry + Barware
    • All Pantry + Barware
    • Breakfast
      • All Breakfast
      • Jams + Jellies
    • Supper
    • Snacks
    • Sweets
    • Coffee
    • Syrups
    • Cocktails
    • Spice Blends
    • Honey
  • Home
    • Kitchenware
      • All Kitchenware
      • Kitchen Linens
      • Mugs
      • Drinkware
      • Serveware
    • Decor
      • All Decor
      • Prints
      • Pillows + Throws
      • Pennants + Camp Flags
      • Doormats
    • Books
      • All Books
      • Cookbooks
      • Children's Books
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Paper Goods
      • All Paper Goods
      • Cards
      • Stickers
      • Magnets
      • Notebooks
      • Notepads
      • Planners + Calendars
    • Candles
    • Soaps + Cleaning
    • Puzzles + Games
  • Personal + Family
    • Apparel
      • Tee Shirts
      • Kids tees + Baby onesies
    • Accessories
    • Kids + Baby
      • Kids Tees + Baby Onesies
      • Childhood Toys
      • Children's Books
    • Pets
      • All Pets
      • Dog Toys
      • Pet Accessories
    • Grooming
    • Travel
  • Outdoors + Grilling
    • Camping
    • Grilling
    • Spice Blends
    • Backyard
    • Garden
  • SALE

Christmas Kitchen

Quick view
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic
$16.00
Quick view
Markham & Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Dark
$16.00
Quick view
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
$13.00
Sold Out
Bourbon Pecans
$12.50
Sold Out
Cinnamon and Sugar Pecans
$7.75
Sold Out
Sparkle Maple Syrup
$16.95
Sold Out
Moonshine Pecans
$12.50
Sold Out
Mexican Hot Chocolate - Almond
$12.00
Quick view
Gold Champagne Marshmallows
$24.00
Sold Out
Weekend Waterford Reusable Cups
$30.00
Quick view
Peppermint Chip Marshmallows - 12 Ct
$11.99
Sold Out
Cinnamon Marshmallows
$11.99
Quick view
Making Spirits Bright Kitchen Towel
$18.00
Quick view
Brass Bottle Opener - Making Spirits Brights
$28.00
Quick view
Snuggle Season Mug
$24.00
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic
Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic

Markham and Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Classic

Regular price $16.00

Pure chocolate shavings from our Single-Origin 60% Colombia Chocolate.  Perfect for whisking into milk to make the most decadent hot chocolate you can imagine!

6 oz. bag

Markham & Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Dark
Markham & Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Dark
Markham & Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Dark
Markham & Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Dark

Markham & Fitz: Drinking Chocolate - Dark

Regular price $16.00

75% Haiti dark chocolate shavings for whisking into hot milk over the stove. Rich and thick and chocolatey, like a European hot chocolate. 

6 oz bag. Makes 6 servings.

Ingredients: organic cacao, organic cane sugar

Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup
Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup

Pink House Alchemy: Winter Mint Syrup

Regular price $13.00

Winter Mint is fresh and light. A powerful bouquet of fresh peppermint, wintergreen, and spearmint is sure to awaken even the sleepiest of winter hibernators. We love the partnership of cold winter months and minty cool flavors. Pour a little in your morning cup of coffee for a minty surprise!

Ingredients: cane sugar, filtered water, peppermint, wintergreen, spearmint, peppermint extract, lactic acid


Gold Champagne Marshmallows
Gold Champagne Marshmallows
Gold Champagne Marshmallows
Gold Champagne Marshmallows

Gold Champagne Marshmallows

Regular price $24.00

Indulge in some real luxury! These marshmallows are cooked with champagne, then hand-painted with 24 karat edible gold. Each bite is light as air and makes for a truly indulgent treat. All of our marshmallows are made with real cane sugar, for a crisper "sweet" and a better aftertaste. Gluten-Free and made with Kosher ingredients.

Each box of 16 marshmallows is packaged in lovingly foil-stamped, American-made paper. 

Peppermint Chip Marshmallows - 12 Ct
Peppermint Chip Marshmallows - 12 Ct
Peppermint Chip Marshmallows - 12 Ct
Peppermint Chip Marshmallows - 12 Ct

Peppermint Chip Marshmallows - 12 Ct

Regular price $11.99
To maintain freshness, your marshmallows should be stored in a cool, dark place. Our shelf life is listed at 14 weeks to ensure quality, freshness and the fluffiness our customers have come to expect. As this being a perishable item, we will not accept returns or exchanges.
Making Spirits Bright Kitchen Towel
Making Spirits Bright Kitchen Towel
Making Spirits Bright Kitchen Towel
Making Spirits Bright Kitchen Towel

Making Spirits Bright Kitchen Towel

Regular price $18.00

Size 27 1/2" x 20".

Features an original hand illustrated distressed pattern. Premium 100% cotton. Gold color.

Brass Bottle Opener - Making Spirits Brights
Brass Bottle Opener - Making Spirits Brights

Brass Bottle Opener - Making Spirits Brights

Regular price $28.00
perfect for the cocktail connoisseur!
Snuggle Season Mug
Snuggle Season Mug
Snuggle Season Mug
Snuggle Season Mug

Snuggle Season Mug

Regular price $24.00

11oz mug.

The white text is on both sides of the mug (the design is screen-printed and NOT a decal/sticker).

Please note: we recommend hand washing this item. Microwave safe.

Footer menu

  • Return Policy and Return Portal
  • Online and In-store Support and FAQ
  • Search
  • PRIVACY POLICY

Sign up and save

Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals.

Our shop is dog friendly. Please come stop in and say hi and/or buy stuff.

Looking for us?  Something else nagging you? Give us a shout.

Phone No. 479-304-8459

For General inquiries and order questions, hit up citysupplyfayetteville@gmail.com.

COME VISIT!

15 S. BLOCK AVENUE SUITE 101

FAYETTEVILLE, AR 72701

(ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE SQUARE)

  • amazon payments
  • american express
  • apple pay
  • discover
  • google pay
  • master
  • visa