Gifts for the Impossible

Discover the perfect presents for the hardest-to-shop-for individuals on your list with our City Supply Gifts for the Impossible Collection! This curated selection features unique and unexpected gifts that will delight even the trickiest recipients. From a stylish champagne saber—something you never knew you needed—to a variety of whimsical and practical items, this collection is designed to inspire and impress. Make gift-giving an adventure and ensure everyone on your list feels celebrated with these extraordinary finds!

22 Results

Champagne Saber

Champagne Saber

$124.99

Unit price
per 

Bittermilk x Pappy & Co: Old Fashioned Mix
Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Pepper Sauce

Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Pepper Sauce

$14.99

Unit price
per 

Jack Rudy: Bourbon Cocktail Cherries

Jack Rudy: Bourbon Cocktail Cherries

$21.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Bourbon Barrel-aged Maple Syrup
Gift Card

Gift Card

from $10.00

Unit price
per 

Square packages surround a dark amber glass candle, scattered around wooden matches.
ARKANSAS MAKER
Jack Rudy: Jack Pack Gift Set

Jack Rudy: Jack Pack Gift Set

$49.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Pappy Bottle Canvas Dog Toy

Pappy & Co: Pappy Bottle Canvas Dog Toy

$24.99

Unit price
per 

Nebo: Big Poppy

Nebo: Big Poppy

$34.99

Unit price
per 

Nebo: Blackout Backup Emergency LED Bulb

Nebo: Blackout Backup Emergency LED Bulb

$11.99

Unit price
per 

Nebo: TRANSCEND 1500 RECHARGEABLE HEADLAMP
Nebo: OMNI 3K WORK LIGHT

Nebo: OMNI 3K WORK LIGHT

$64.99

Unit price
per 

Baseball BBQ: ARKANSAS CUTTING BOARD 17"
$33.00 off

Baseball BBQ: ARKANSAS CUTTING BOARD 17"

Regular price $109.99 $76.99 30% off

Unit price
per 

Nebo: Luxtreme SL25R Floodlight + Spotlight
Cocktail Smoker Kit

Cocktail Smoker Kit

$99.99

Unit price
per 

Nebo: RAMBLER 200 PORTABLE POWER STATION

Nebo: RAMBLER 200 PORTABLE POWER STATION

$299.99

Unit price
per 

Nebo: INTREPID 600 POWER STATION

Nebo: INTREPID 600 POWER STATION

$599.99

Unit price
per 

Nebo: ASSIST AIR JUMP STARTER

Nebo: ASSIST AIR JUMP STARTER

$179.99

Unit price
per 

Ralph Lauren A Way of Living Book
Sold out

Ralph Lauren A Way of Living Book

$75.99

Unit price
per