Products

Posts & Pages

View all results

A modern day mercantile, City Supply houses curated homestead provisions and goods with nostalgia.  Gifts, pantry goods, locally influenced tee shirts and inspired home goods to give... or keep for yourself. Come in and say hi/and or buy stuff as we're located on the historic downtown Fayetteville square.

  • New Arrivals
  • Gifts
    • Gift Card
    • Gifts for Him
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Baby
    • Teacher Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Housewarming Gifts
    • Wedding Gifts
    • Gifts Under $30
  • Collections
    • Father's Day
      • Father's Day: The Outdoorsman
      • Father's Day: The History Buff
      • Father's Day: The Grill Master
      • Father's Day: The Cocktail Connoisseur
    • Lake
    • 2022 Graduation
    • Tequila + Tex Mex
    • Arkansas Razorbacks
    • Fayetteville, Arkansas
    • City Supply Exclusives
    • Bloody Mary Morning
    • Arkansas Makers
    • National Parks
  • Shop by Brand
    • Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
    • Bittermilk
    • Camp Arkansas
    • Cotton Clara
    • Duncan + Stone
    • Em + Friends
    • Finex
    • Guenther Apiary
    • Hammond's Candies
    • Haute Diggity Dog
    • House of Webster
    • Jack Rudy
    • Lost & Found Collective
    • Lovestruck Co
    • Lucy & Co
    • Mollyjogger
    • Old School Mill
    • The Old Try
    • Onyx Coffee Lab
    • Oxford Pennant
    • Pappy & Co
    • Parks Project
    • Petersen Family Farms
    • Pink House Alchemy
    • The Real Dill
    • Signet Sealed Illustration
    • Sip Hip Hooray
    • Slightly Stationary
    • Spiceology
    • Stanley
    • Sugarboo & Co
    • Walker's Feed Co
    • Well Told
    • War Eagle Mill
    • Wright's Barbecue
  • Pantry + Barware
    • All Pantry + Barware
    • Breakfast
      • All Breakfast
      • Jams + Jellies
    • Supper
    • Snacks
    • Sweets
    • Coffee + Tea
    • Syrups
    • Cocktails
    • Spice Blends
    • Honey
  • Home
    • Kitchenware
      • All Kitchenware
      • Cast Iron
      • Kitchen Linens
      • Mugs
      • Drinkware
      • Serveware
    • Decor
      • All Decor
      • Prints
      • Pillows + Throws
      • Pennants + Camp Flags
      • Doormats
    • Books
      • All Books
      • Cookbooks
      • Children's Books
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Paper Goods
      • All Paper Goods
      • Cards
      • Stickers
      • Magnets
      • Notebooks
      • Notepads
      • Planners + Calendars
    • Candles
    • Soaps + Cleaning
    • Puzzles + Games
  • Personal + Family
    • Apparel
      • Tee Shirts + Sweatshirts
      • Hats
      • Razorback Kid's Clothing
      • Kids tees + Baby onesies
    • Accessories
    • Kids + Baby
      • Kids Tees + Baby Onesies
      • Childhood Toys
      • Children's Books
    • Pets
      • All Pets
      • Dog Toys
      • Pet Accessories
    • Grooming
    • Travel
  • Outdoors + Grilling
    • Camping
    • Grilling
    • Spice Blends
    • Backyard
    • Garden
  • Sale
  • New Arrivals
  • Gifts
    • Gift Card
    • Gifts for Him
    • Gifts for Her
    • Gifts for Baby
    • Teacher Gifts
    • Hostess Gifts
    • Housewarming Gifts
    • Wedding Gifts
    • Gifts Under $30
  • Collections
    • Father's Day
      • Father's Day: The Outdoorsman
      • Father's Day: The History Buff
      • Father's Day: The Grill Master
      • Father's Day: The Cocktail Connoisseur
    • Lake
    • 2022 Graduation
    • Tequila + Tex Mex
    • Arkansas Razorbacks
    • Fayetteville, Arkansas
    • City Supply Exclusives
    • Bloody Mary Morning
    • Arkansas Makers
    • National Parks
  • Shop by Brand
    • Arsaga's Coffee Roasters
    • Bittermilk
    • Camp Arkansas
    • Cotton Clara
    • Duncan + Stone
    • Em + Friends
    • Finex
    • Guenther Apiary
    • Hammond's Candies
    • Haute Diggity Dog
    • House of Webster
    • Jack Rudy
    • Lost & Found Collective
    • Lovestruck Co
    • Lucy & Co
    • Mollyjogger
    • Old School Mill
    • The Old Try
    • Onyx Coffee Lab
    • Oxford Pennant
    • Pappy & Co
    • Parks Project
    • Petersen Family Farms
    • Pink House Alchemy
    • The Real Dill
    • Signet Sealed Illustration
    • Sip Hip Hooray
    • Slightly Stationary
    • Spiceology
    • Stanley
    • Sugarboo & Co
    • Walker's Feed Co
    • Well Told
    • War Eagle Mill
    • Wright's Barbecue
  • Pantry + Barware
    • All Pantry + Barware
    • Breakfast
      • All Breakfast
      • Jams + Jellies
    • Supper
    • Snacks
    • Sweets
    • Coffee + Tea
    • Syrups
    • Cocktails
    • Spice Blends
    • Honey
  • Home
    • Kitchenware
      • All Kitchenware
      • Cast Iron
      • Kitchen Linens
      • Mugs
      • Drinkware
      • Serveware
    • Decor
      • All Decor
      • Prints
      • Pillows + Throws
      • Pennants + Camp Flags
      • Doormats
    • Books
      • All Books
      • Cookbooks
      • Children's Books
      • Coffee Table Books
    • Paper Goods
      • All Paper Goods
      • Cards
      • Stickers
      • Magnets
      • Notebooks
      • Notepads
      • Planners + Calendars
    • Candles
    • Soaps + Cleaning
    • Puzzles + Games
  • Personal + Family
    • Apparel
      • Tee Shirts + Sweatshirts
      • Hats
      • Razorback Kid's Clothing
      • Kids tees + Baby onesies
    • Accessories
    • Kids + Baby
      • Kids Tees + Baby Onesies
      • Childhood Toys
      • Children's Books
    • Pets
      • All Pets
      • Dog Toys
      • Pet Accessories
    • Grooming
    • Travel
  • Outdoors + Grilling
    • Camping
    • Grilling
    • Spice Blends
    • Backyard
    • Garden
  • Sale
Home / Collections / Gifts for Him

Gifts for Him

  • Bittermilk x Pappy & Co: Old Fashioned Mix

    $19.50

    Bittermilk x Pappy & Co: Old Fashioned Mix

    $19.50
  • Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Pepper Sauce

    $14.00

    Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Pepper Sauce

    $14.00
  • Wright's BBQ: Sauce - Bold

    $8.00

    Wright's BBQ: Sauce - Bold

    $8.00
  • Fayetteville, AR Map Rocks Glass

    $16.50

    Fayetteville, AR Map Rocks Glass

    $16.50
  • Bittermilk: Bourbon Barrel-aged Old Fashioned Syrup

    $15.00

    Bittermilk: Bourbon Barrel-aged Old Fashioned Syrup

    $15.00
  • Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Coffee

    $24.00

    Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Coffee

    $24.00
  • Jack Rudy: Bourbon Cocktail Cherries

    $15.00

    Jack Rudy: Bourbon Cocktail Cherries

    $15.00
  • Pappy & Co: Bourbon Barrel-aged Old Fashioned Mix: Single Serve 5-pack

    $19.50

    Pappy & Co: Bourbon Barrel-aged Old Fashioned Mix: Single Serve 5-pack

    $19.50
  • Lost & Found Collective: Maxine’s Taproom Tales

    $28.00

    Lost & Found Collective: Maxine’s Taproom Tales

    $28.00
  • Fayetteville, AR Map Pint Glass

    $18.00

    Fayetteville, AR Map Pint Glass

    $18.00
  • Billy Graham In Quotes

    $15.99

    Billy Graham In Quotes

    $15.99
  • Feltner Brothers: Feltner Sauce

    $10.00

    Feltner Brothers: Feltner Sauce

    $10.00
  • Pappy & Co: Bourbon Barrel-aged Maple Syrup

    $38.00

    Pappy & Co: Bourbon Barrel-aged Maple Syrup

    $38.00
  • Bittermilk: Smoked Honey Whiskey Sour

    $19.00

    Bittermilk: Smoked Honey Whiskey Sour

    $19.00
  • Bittermilk: Single Serve Bourbon Barrel-aged Old Fashioned 5-Pack

    $15.00

    Bittermilk: Single Serve Bourbon Barrel-aged Old Fashioned 5-Pack

    $15.00
  • Arkansas Cork Coasters - Set of 2

    $14.50

    Arkansas Cork Coasters - Set of 2

    $14.50
  • Arkansas Campgrounds 24x36 Print (2nd Edition)

    $24.00

    Arkansas Campgrounds 24x36 Print (2nd Edition)

    $24.00
  • Bittermilk: Old Fashioned Set

    $45.00

    Bittermilk: Old Fashioned Set

    $45.00
  • University of Arkansas Campus Map Pint Pair

    $30.00

    University of Arkansas Campus Map Pint Pair

    $30.00
  • Arnold Palmer's Success Lessons

    $14.99

    Arnold Palmer's Success Lessons

    $14.99
  • We The People Rocks Glass

    $14.50

    We The People Rocks Glass

    $14.50
  • On sale

    Solo Stove: Bonfire + Stand Bundle

    $419.99 $359.00

    Solo Stove: Bonfire + Stand Bundle

    $419.99 $359.00
  • Declaration Of Independence Rocks Glass

    $14.50

    Declaration Of Independence Rocks Glass

    $14.50
  • Spiceology: Grill Greats Mini Rub Set

    $38.00

    Spiceology: Grill Greats Mini Rub Set

    $38.00
  • Father to Daughter

    $9.95

    Father to Daughter

    $9.95
  • Bittermilk: Oaxaca Old Fashioned Syrup

    $15.00

    Bittermilk: Oaxaca Old Fashioned Syrup

    $15.00
  • Sold out

    Recipes from the World of Tolkien

    $19.99

    Recipes from the World of Tolkien

    $19.99
  • Bittermilk: New Orleans Style Old Fashioned Rouge

    $15.00

    Bittermilk: New Orleans Style Old Fashioned Rouge

    $15.00
  • Father to Son

    $9.95

    Father to Son

    $9.95
  • Don'ts for Golfers

    $5.95

    Don'ts for Golfers

    $5.95
  • Spiceology: Beer Infused Six Pack Spice Pack

    $69.99

    Spiceology: Beer Infused Six Pack Spice Pack

    $69.99
  • Stanley: Classic Wide Mouth Flask

    $28.00

    Stanley: Classic Wide Mouth Flask

    $28.00
  • Pappyland

    $27.00

    Pappyland

    $27.00
  • Sold out

    Bittermilk: The Variety Show

    $45.00

    Bittermilk: The Variety Show

    $45.00
  • Sold out

    Duncan & Stone: Legacy Journal

    $30.00

    Duncan & Stone: Legacy Journal

    $30.00
  • Arkansas Weekend T-Shirt (City Supply Exclusive)

    $32.00

    Arkansas Weekend T-Shirt (City Supply Exclusive)

    $32.00
  • Sold out

    Pappy & Co: Pappy Hour Reusable Cups

    $24.00

    Pappy & Co: Pappy Hour Reusable Cups

    $24.00
  • Sold out

    Really Bad Dad Jokes

    $9.99

    Really Bad Dad Jokes

    $9.99
  • Roll Me Up and Smoke Me When I Die

    $15.99

    Roll Me Up and Smoke Me When I Die

    $15.99
  • Whiskey Years Card

    $5.00

    Whiskey Years Card

    $5.00
  • Spiceology: Steak Lovers Gift Set

    $36.00

    Spiceology: Steak Lovers Gift Set

    $36.00
  • Men In Green

    $17.00

    Men In Green

    $17.00
  • Johnny Cash Diner Mug

    $20.00

    Johnny Cash Diner Mug

    $20.00
  • Sold out

    Key Chain Tape Measure

    $4.00

    Key Chain Tape Measure

    $4.00
  • Previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 5
  • Next
  • Our shop is dog friendly. Please come stop in and say hi and/or buy stuff.

    Looking for us?  Something else nagging you? Give us a shout.

    Phone No. 479-304-8459

    For General inquiries and order questions, hit up citysupplyfayetteville@gmail.com.

    • Return Policy and Return Portal
    • Corporate and Bulk Gifting
    • Donation Requests
    • Online and In-store Support and FAQ
    • Privacy Policy
    • Return Policy and Return Portal
    • Corporate and Bulk Gifting
    • Donation Requests
    • Online and In-store Support and FAQ
    • Privacy Policy

© 2022. All rights reserved.

Powered by Shopify

  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Facebook Pay
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa