Skip to content

citysupplyfayetteville

SALE

citysupplyfayetteville

The Gift Guide
Holiday Shop
New + Notable
The General Store
Arkansas
Shop By Brand
Shop By Collection
SALE

Register / Login

Popular collections

Arkansas Makers

Nostalgia + Novelty

Gifts, goods and provisions that are nostalgic of years gone by, our childhoods, and bring joy to our past generations.

58 Results

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

The Heirloomist- 100 Treasures and the Stories they Tell

The Heirloomist- 100 Treasures and the Stories they Tell

$31.99

Unit price: per

MoonPie + RC Cola plush

MoonPie + RC Cola plush

$20.99

Unit price: per

SKIPBO

SKIPBO

$18.99

Unit price: per

Rock 'Em Sock 'Em Robots

Rock 'Em Sock 'Em Robots

$41.99

Unit price: per

Classics Cage Bingo

Classics Cage Bingo

$41.99

Unit price: per

Game of Life- Original 1960's Version

Game of Life- Original 1960's Version

$61.99

Unit price: per

Classic Twister

Classic Twister

$41.99

Unit price: per

Classic Trouble - Exciting Retro 1960's Edition

Classic Trouble - Exciting Retro 1960's Edition

$29.99

Unit price: per

Classic Sorry - 1930's Edition

Classic Sorry - 1930's Edition

$31.99

Unit price: per

12" Arkansas Animated/Musical Santa

12" Arkansas Animated/Musical Santa

$89.99

Unit price: per

Crayola Silly Putty – 2 Count Glow Egg Pack

Crayola Silly Putty – 2 Count Glow Egg Pack

$6.99

Unit price: per

Wooden Catch Ball

Wooden Catch Ball

$7.99

Unit price: per

Footzy Ball - Sporty Fidget Skill Toy

Footzy Ball - Sporty Fidget Skill Toy

$21.99

Unit price: per

Pinky Ball

Pinky Ball

$3.99

Unit price: per

Flashing Skip Ball

Flashing Skip Ball

$10.99

Unit price: per

Crayola Silly Putty – 2 Count Scented Eggs

Crayola Silly Putty – 2 Count Scented Eggs

$6.99

Unit price: per

Left Center Right in Tube

Left Center Right in Tube

$10.99

Unit price: per

Swiv-A-Ball

Swiv-A-Ball

$18.99

Unit price: per

More Best of Mad Libs

More Best of Mad Libs

$7.99

Unit price: per

Koosh 3 Pack Mini Ball Set

Koosh 3 Pack Mini Ball Set

$16.99

Unit price: per

Chicken Flingers

Chicken Flingers

$5.99

Unit price: per

Neato! Hand Buzzer

Neato! Hand Buzzer

$6.99

Unit price: per

Imperial YoYo

Sold out

Imperial YoYo

$6.99

Unit price: per

Wonder Spring

Wonder Spring

$8.99

Unit price: per

Broken Bow: Back When We Were Kids Poster Print

Broken Bow: Back When We Were Kids Poster Print

$27.99

Unit price: per

Broken Bow: Nostalgia Poster Print

Broken Bow: Nostalgia Poster Print

$22.99

Unit price: per

1
2

You’re viewing 33-58 of 58 products

Sort

Featured
Most relevant
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old

SHOP MORE COLLECTIONS

OUR MOST POPULAR

Arkansas Makers

Arkansas Makers

City Supply Exclusives + Collaborations

City Supply Exclusives + Collaborations

A bottle of Wright's Barbecue BBQ Sauce Original sits among a cooler and other tailgate items. The clear bottle showcases the barbecue's dark brown tones.

Bestsellers

Razorbacks

Razorbacks

Pantry + Barware

Pantry + Barware

Books

Books

Outdoors

Outdoors

Our shop is dog friendly. Please come stop in and say hi and/or buy stuff.

Looking for us? Something else nagging you? Give us a shout.

Phone No. 479-304-8459

For General inquiries and order questions, hit up citysupplyfayetteville@gmail.com.

INFORMATION + LINKS

Texting Is Easier! Join now.
Holler at us.
About Us: City Supply + The Mormans
Customer Service
Shipping
Collabs + Affiliates
In-Store Sweets + Treats
Corporate + Bulk Gifting
Return Policy + Returns
Donation Requests
Frequently Asked Questions
Privacy Policy

STORE HOURS

monday-saturday 10am-6pm

sunday NOON-5PM

15 S. BLOCK AVENUE

FAYETTEVILLE AR, 72701

Newsletter

Your email

Copyright © 2026, citysupplyfayetteville. All rights reserved. See our terms of use and privacy notice.

Powered by Shopify

Availability