Whiskey Collection

Indulge in the art of sipping with our City Supply Whiskey Collection! Elevate your drinking experience with our elegant rocks glasses, perfect for savoring your favorite pours. Discover the crowd-pleasing Bittermilk Old Fashioned mixes, a bestseller that adds a sophisticated twist to your cocktail repertoire. And for those who appreciate the finer things, our Pappy Van Winkle syrups and gifts make for the ultimate addition to any whiskey lover's collection. Whether you're treating yourself or searching for the perfect gift, this collection has everything you need to celebrate the spirit of whiskey!

31 Results

A bottle of Bittermilk Old Fashioned Mix sits on a wooden surface, in front of a brick wall, accompanies with playing cards, wooden matches, trophies.
Bittermilk: Smoked Honey Whiskey Sour

Bittermilk: Smoked Honey Whiskey Sour

$18.99

Unit price
per 

Bittermilk: Tom Collins Elderflower + Hops
Gentleman Jack: Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mix
Gentleman Jack: Whiskey Sour Cocktail Mix - 2oz
Bittermilk x Pappy & Co: Old Fashioned Mix
Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Pepper Sauce

Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Pepper Sauce

$14.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Coffee

Pappy & Co: Barrel-aged Coffee

$24.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Bourbon Barrel-aged Maple Syrup
Bittermilk: Old Fashioned Set

Bittermilk: Old Fashioned Set

$54.99

Unit price
per 

Whiskey Years Card

Whiskey Years Card

$5.99

Unit price
per 

Bittermilk: Charred Grapefruit Tonic

Bittermilk: Charred Grapefruit Tonic

$19.99

Unit price
per 

The New Kindred Spirits

The New Kindred Spirits

$50.00

Unit price
per 

You're Neat Reusable Cups

You're Neat Reusable Cups

$21.99

Unit price
per 

Jack Rudy: Maple Syrup

Jack Rudy: Maple Syrup

$20.99

Unit price
per 

Jack Rudy: Hawthorne Strainer

Jack Rudy: Hawthorne Strainer

$10.99

Unit price
per 

Pappy & Co: Pappy Bottle Canvas Dog Toy

Pappy & Co: Pappy Bottle Canvas Dog Toy

$24.99

Unit price
per 

Dapper Chap 'On The Rocks' 9 Whiskey Stones
Old Try - Coffee, Whiskey, Grace

Old Try - Coffee, Whiskey, Grace

$42.99

Unit price
per 

Hot Toddy Mix - 8 fl oz

Hot Toddy Mix - 8 fl oz

$12.99

Unit price
per 

Cocktail Smoker Kit

Cocktail Smoker Kit

$99.99

Unit price
per 

Whiskey Pillow w/ Embroidery

Whiskey Pillow w/ Embroidery

$25.99

Unit price
per 

Stainless Steel Horse Head Jigger

Stainless Steel Horse Head Jigger

$14.99

Unit price
per 

Golf Ball Ice Mold

Golf Ball Ice Mold

$14.99

Unit price
per 

Bourbon Closer Tea Towel

Bourbon Closer Tea Towel

$14.99

Unit price
per 

A Day at the Masters Acrylic Stir Sticks

A Day at the Masters Acrylic Stir Sticks

$21.99

Unit price
per 

Derby Horse Acrylic Stir Sticks
Sold out

Derby Horse Acrylic Stir Sticks

$19.99

Unit price
per 

Take me to the Masters Stir Sticks

Take me to the Masters Stir Sticks

$22.99

Unit price
per 

We're Headed to the Masters Acrylic Stir Sticks