Cross off that Christmas LIst!
Our Favorite Gifts
A curated collection of the gifts we love to give (and hope to receive).
These are the things we reach for year after year — and a few new finds we can’t stop talking about. From Arkansas-made favorites and cozy kitchen staples to luxe surprises and nostalgic keepsakes, every item in this collection has a story behind it.
Whether you’re shopping for the perfect host gift, a thoughtful stocking stuffer, or something just for you, these are the pieces that make holiday gifting feel personal, timeless, and full of Fayetteville spirit.
— Kirsten & Chase Morman
'Tis the season
The Christmas Collection
Step inside the magic of the season at City Supply — where tradition meets Arkansas charm. Our Christmas Collection is filled with nostalgic gifts, cozy finds, and locally made favorites that celebrate home, heritage, and holiday spirit. Whether you’re decking the halls, gifting thoughtfully, or simply soaking in the season, this collection brings the warmth of Fayetteville Christmases past and present to life.
the tailgate collection
Game day starts here. Our Tailgate Collection is built for Razorback Saturdays, backyard gatherings, and every pre-game celebration in between. From laid-back layers and must-have hats to accessories that show your Arkansas pride, this collection makes it easy to cheer, grill, and celebrate in style. Whether you’re headed to the stadium or setting up the ultimate tailgate at home, these pieces are designed to keep you comfortable, spirited, and game-day ready.
About City Supply + The Mormans
Welcome to City Supply, where nostalgia meets modern living. Our inviting storefront offers a unique shopping experience filled with essential housewares and gifts, from award-winning Bloody Mary mixes to seasonal candles and humorous dog toys. Established in 2018, we aim to connect the past with quality and inspiring products for everyday life. As a family-owned business, we are dedicated to curating a product mix that reflects our personal style and serves our community. We invite you to visit us and explore our carefully selected items!
CITY SUPPLY X LOST & FOUND CO.
MONTHLY CANDLE SUBSCRIPTION
Our greatest gift idea, we have curated a signature City Supply scent for each month of the year hand poured here in Fayetteville by our friends at Lost & Found Co. Join the subscription and save 10% each month!
By completing this form, you are signing up to receive our emails and can unsubscribe at any time.
nostalgic housewares + gifts
Drawing a connection between items that exude quality and tradition, and also connect us with items that evolve and inspire a life well lived.
You will find us in every aspect of our small team of go-getters! Shipping, stocking, marketing and curating a product list you can rely on. We are truly a family owned and operated small business and we plan on keeping it that way!
"The descriptions and pictures for the products online are perfect and shipping is so quick. One of my favorite small shops with the most unique items!"– Google review